Customer complaints and the right to repair: why the first contact now matters

Titelkarte: Reklamationen – Was das Recht auf Reparatur für den ersten Kontakt bedeutet

A customer calls because their dishwasher has stopped draining after eight months. Until recently, this was routine: log the defect, offer a repair or a replacement, close the ticket. Since 31 July 2026, more depends on that first conversation. Under the EU directive on the “right to repair”, as implemented in Germany, sellers must tell consumers – before they choose between repair and replacement – that choosing a repair extends the legal guarantee period once by twelve months. If customer service does not record clearly when and how this information was given, the business has a problem as soon as a dispute arises.

This article shows how small and mid-sized companies can set up complaint handling so that defect claims run reliably from the first contact to resolution. It refers to consumer sales contracts concluded in Germany on or after 31 July 2026, based on Directive (EU) 2024/1799. Other EU member states have transposed the same directive with their own national rules, and contracts with business customers or older contracts are partly governed by different provisions. It is not legal advice.

What has changed since 31 July 2026

Consumers already had the right to choose between repair and replacement. Three things are new:

  • Extension after repair: If the customer chooses repair, the running limitation period for defect claims is extended once by twelve months – provided the period has not yet expired and the repair is actually carried out.
  • Information before the choice: The seller must explain both options and the extension before the customer decides. The Frankfurt Chamber of Commerce (IHK) explicitly recommends building this into the complaint process itself; in its view, a paragraph in the terms and conditions or the FAQ is not enough.
  • Loan device as an option: For the duration of the repair, the seller may provide a replacement device free of charge, including a refurbished one. This is not mandatory. For a replacement delivery, however, refurbished goods may only be supplied if the customer explicitly requests them.

In addition, for certain product groups such as washing machines, refrigerators, smartphones, tablets and e-scooters, consumers now have a right to repair against the manufacturer, even after the legal guarantee has expired. For retailers, this means more enquiries in which the first step is to clarify who is actually responsible.

The first contact shapes the whole case

Most complaints do not fail because of the repair itself but because of incomplete information at the start. A structured first contact saves follow-up questions and creates the documentation the new rules require. A fixed intake form in the ticket with these mandatory fields has proven effective:

  • Date of purchase and receipt, order or invoice number, serial number
  • Description of the fault in the customer’s own words, plus photos or a short video
  • Whether the case falls under the legal guarantee, a manufacturer’s warranty or a paid repair
  • Information given on repair, replacement and the extended period – with time and channel
  • The option chosen by the customer

With complaints made by phone, the fourth and fifth points are the tricky ones. A short, agreed sentence in the call script helps, together with an automatic email template that confirms the information in writing.

Separate legal guarantee, warranty and goodwill

In everyday work, these terms are often mixed up – by service teams too. For case handling, however, the distinction is essential. The legal guarantee is the statutory claim against the seller. A warranty is a voluntary promise, usually from the manufacturer, with its own conditions. Goodwill is a decision made without legal obligation. And the new right to repair against the manufacturer only applies once there is no longer a claim against the seller.

If these categories are kept as a mandatory field in the ticket, cases can be routed automatically to the right place: legal guarantee cases into in-house processing, warranty cases with all documents to the manufacturer, goodwill requests to the person authorised to decide. This shortens lead times and prevents customers from being sent back and forth between retailer and manufacturer.

Keep deadlines and status in view

The law sets no fixed maximum duration for a repair, but it requires a reasonable period without significant inconvenience for the customer. Internally, you therefore need your own targets – for example for acknowledgement of receipt, diagnosis and return shipment – stored as deadlines in the ticket system that trigger a reminder before they expire.

Communication in between is just as important. Someone who has sent in a device and hears nothing for ten days will call – creating an avoidable contact. Automatic status messages when the goods arrive, after diagnosis and on dispatch keep customers informed. Each message should open a way back into the same ticket so that follow-up questions do not start as a new case.

Document the extended period

The twelve additional months arise per device and per repair. If the same customer returns a year later with another defect, the service team must be able to see at once whether the period was extended and until when it runs. That only works if the completion date of the repair is stored in the customer record – ideally linked to the product or its serial number, not just buried in a closed email.

In myContactCenter, you can create custom fields in the ticket, store templates for the required information and link deadlines with escalation rules. Through the CRM integration, previous repairs appear directly in the customer context during the next call. Phone, email, chat and WhatsApp come together in one case, so the record stays complete regardless of channel.

Conclusion: treat complaints as a process, not as one-off cases

The right to repair turns the first contact into a legally relevant moment. Companies that set up their complaint handling with mandatory fields, clear categories, internal deadlines and complete documentation do more than meet the new information duties. They also resolve defect claims faster and with fewer follow-up questions.

Would you like to see how your complaint process could be mapped in myContactCenter? Book a free consultation with ilogixx via our online calendar at ilogixx.de.

Read more